OXO vs Simplehuman Paper Towel Holder – Which One Fits for You?

A paper towel holder may seem like a small detail in the kitchen, yet the right one can make daily tasks smoother and more convenient. Two of the most popular choices are the OXO paper towel holder and the Simplehuman paper towel holder.

Both brands focus on sleek design and practical function, but each offers unique features that set them apart. OXO designs with stability and easy tearing in mind, making it a favorite for busy households.

Simplehuman emphasizes modern style and durability, giving kitchens a polished and organized look. Price, build quality, and user experience also play a big role in the decision.

A closer look at both options reveals the strengths and weaknesses of each, helping you decide which one matches your space and lifestyle. Small upgrades like this can bring a big difference to everyday routines in the kitchen.

OXO Paper Towel Holder vs Simplehuman Paper Towel Holder

A paper towel holder might seem like a small kitchen accessory. But the right one can save time, reduce waste, and keep countertops neat. Two popular choices are the OXO SimplyTear Paper Towel Holder and the Simplehuman Paper Towel Holder.

Both are made of stainless steel and built for stability, but they use different designs to hold and dispense rolls. Let’s break them down.

OXO Good Grips Paper Towel Holder

 

Product Details

The OXO SimplyTear Paper Towel Holder is made of stainless steel with a freestanding design. It measures about 13 inches tall and 7 inches wide, and weighs 1.2 pounds. The holder works with any paper towel size or brand.

A spring-activated arm keeps the roll steady, making one-handed tearing possible. The non-slip weighted base prevents movement on countertops, and reloading is quick thanks to its internal resistance system.

Features

• Stainless steel freestanding design

• Spring-activated arm for one-handed tearing

• Non-slip weighted base

• Works with any paper towel size or brand

• Measures 7 x 7 x 13 inches

• Easy reload system

What is the good?

The OXO holder makes tearing a single sheet simple. The weighted base keeps it steady, so the roll doesn’t slide around. It accepts all brands and roll sizes, so you don’t need special refills. The design is sleek and compact, which fits well in most kitchens. Reloading the roll is also quick and easy.

What is the bad?

The holder is lighter compared to some other models, which might not feel as solid for heavy-duty use. The spring arm may press too tightly on smaller rolls, making the first few sheets harder to pull.

Overall Opinion

The OXO SimplyTear Paper Towel Holder is a good balance of price, function, and style. It works well for daily use, especially if you want a versatile holder that fits all roll types.

Simplehuman Standing Paper Towel Holder

 

Product Details

The Simplehuman Paper Towel Holder is also made of stainless steel but comes in a black finish for a modern look. It measures 8 inches long and 7 inches wide, weighing 2.65 pounds.

The holder uses a precision-tuned tension arm to allow tearing one or multiple sheets with ease. A weighted base adds stability, and a finger loop makes it easier to pick up and move. It is optimized for Simplehuman’s jumbo paper towel rolls but can also work with other brands.

Features

• Stainless steel in black finish

• Precision-tuned tension arm for smooth tearing

• Weighted base for stability

• Finger loop for easy carrying

• Designed for jumbo rolls

• Measures 8 x 7 inches, weight 2.65 pounds

What is the good?

The Simplehuman holder feels sturdy because of its heavier base. The tension arm gives clean tears, whether one sheet or several. The finger loop makes it simple to move around, which is handy in a busy kitchen. The design looks stylish and modern, especially in black stainless steel.

What is the bad?

It is heavier and bulkier than the OXO version, which might not suit smaller counters. It works best with jumbo rolls, so smaller rolls may not sit as firmly. The price is also higher compared to some alternatives.

Overall Opinion

The Simplehuman Paper Towel Holder is ideal for people who use large rolls often and want a durable, stylish design. It is heavier and more stable than the OXO, but it takes up a little more space.

Details Comparison for OXO vs Simplehuman Paper Towel Holder

The OXO SimplyTear is lighter, smaller, and fits all roll sizes, while the Simplehuman holder is heavier, sturdier, and works best with jumbo rolls.

OXO uses a spring-activated arm for one-handed tearing, while Simplehuman uses a tension arm that allows both single and multiple sheet pulls.

The OXO design is easier to reload, while the Simplehuman design focuses more on stability and precision tearing.

Both are freestanding, stainless steel, and built with weighted bases, but Simplehuman offers a more premium look with its black stainless steel finish.

OXO wins on flexibility and compact size, while Simplehuman wins on stability and style.

FAQs

Q: Do both holders work with any brand of paper towels?
Yes, but the OXO fits all sizes better, while the Simplehuman holder is optimized for jumbo rolls.

Q: Which one is better for one-handed use?
Both allow one-handed tearing, but OXO’s spring arm gives stronger resistance, while Simplehuman’s tension arm feels smoother.

Q: Which is more stable on the counter?
The Simplehuman holder is heavier and offers more stability.

Q: Which one is easier to move around?
The Simplehuman holder has a finger loop for easy carrying.

Q: Are both easy to clean?
Yes. Both stainless steel finishes are easy to wipe down.

Conclusion

The choice between the OXO Paper Towel Holder vs Simplehuman Paper Towel Holder depends on your needs. OXO is lighter, compact, and works with any roll size, making it versatile for everyday kitchens.

Simplehuman is heavier, sleek, and stable, making it a better fit for large rolls and modern kitchen styles. Both deliver reliable one-handed tearing, but the difference comes down to space, style, and the type of rolls you prefer.